Performance Management Framework
Performance management at UVM is a continuous cycle of communication, development, feedback, and planning that occurs throughout the year. While annual performance evaluations are an important component of the process, they are only one part of a broader framework designed to support employee success and advance departmental and institutional goals.
We believe effective performance management is critical to the success of both our university and employees. By helping employees understand expectations, develop their skills, recognize accomplishments, address challenges, and connect their work to the mission of UVM, performance management becomes a tool for growth, engagement, accountability, and organizational effectiveness.
The Performance Management Cycle
- Setting Goals and Expectations
- Providing Everyday Feedback
- Making Performance Conversations Routine
- Supporting Performance Improvement
- Conducting Performance Evaluations
Managers have an important role in helping employees understand what success looks like, recognize their contributions, build on their strengths, and identify opportunities to grow. Regular conversations about performance can help employees stay connected to their goals, understand how their work makes an impact, and get the support they need to succeed. Providing a written recap can be helpful to ensure a shared understanding of the conversation.
Setting Goals and Expectations
Overview
Managers and employees work together to set meaningful goals that support individual growth, team priorities, and the university’s broader goals. Regular check-ins help keep goals aligned and recognize progress along the way.
Typically, goals should be logged within ePerformance by April or May of the year since the employee will be evaluated on these goals when the calendar year ends. This way, the employee is clear on their goals for the year.
Establishing Meaningful Goals
A helpful way to develop goals is by using the SMART Goal Framework:
- S-Specific: What will be accomplished? What steps will you take to achieve it? Who will be involved?
- M-Measurable: Your goal should have something you can track. How will you know you're making progress? What data will measure the goal?
- A-Attainable: What can be achieved within a certain timeframe? Do you have the time, resources, skills, and resources?
- R-Relevant: How does the goal align with what matters top your group's work or broader UVM goals? Why is the result important?
- T-Time-Bound: What is the timeframe for accomplishing the goal? What are your deadlines?
Recording goals in PeopleSoft ePerformance
Individual employee goals are recorded within PeopleSoft ePerformance. Goals for the year should be discussed as a part of the performance review process.
- Employee enters 2-3 goals.
- Manager reviews and ensures alignment with job duties and department priorities.
- Once agreed, managers finalize goals by completing the step within ePerformance.
The Goals section of the Performance Evaluation Mini Manual provides screenshots and instructions about how to record goals within the tool.
Resources for completing Performance Evaluation in ePerformance
- Completing annual evaluation in PeopleSoft ePerformance - Manager (PDF)
- Completing annual evaluation in PeopleSoft ePerformance - Employee (PDF)
As a reminder, goals should typically be logged within ePerformance by April or May of the year since the employee will be evaluated on these goals when the calendar year ends. This way, the employee is clear on their goals for the year.
Setting Clear Expectations
Clear expectations help employees understand what success looks like and how their work contributes to organizational goals.
- Set Goals: Make sure employees know what they’re working toward and what success looks like. Use SMART goals to keep goals specific and realistic.
- Connect Work to Bigger Goals: Help employees see how their work supports their team and the university's goals.
- Be Clear About Roles: Make sure employees understand their responsibilities, priorities, what decisions they can make on their own, and when they should include you.
- Talk About Expectations Early and Often: Set expectations upon hire, with new job responsibilities, or at the beginning of a project. Check in regularly as priorities change.
- Clarify Expectations: Encourage questions and open conversation so employees feel comfortable asking for clarification.
- Talk About How Work Gets Done: Expectations should include not only what employees accomplish, but also how they work with others, communicate, and contribute to a positive workplace.
- Offer Support and Resources: Make sure employees know where to turn for help, training, guidance, and feedback when they need it.
Everyday Feedback: A Tool for Growth
Overview
Feedback is one of the most valuable tools a manager has to support employee growth. When feedback is timely, specific, and constructive, it helps employees understand what is working well and where they can make adjustments.
Make feedback part of your everyday practice. Recognize great work when you see it, and address opportunities for improvement early—before they become bigger challenges.
Situation—Behavior—Impact (SBI) Framework
SBI is a simple way to give clear, constructive feedback by describing the situation, the specific behavior you observed, and the impact it had.
- Situation: Describe when and where the specific interaction or event happened.
- Behavior: Describe the specific action or behavior you observed, focusing on what the person did or said rather than making assumptions about their intent.
- Impact: Explain the effect the behavior had on the team, work, or outcome, and why it mattered.
Below are a couple of examples of how feedback can be provided using the SBI Framework.
- Positive Feedback Example:
- Situation: During last week's department meeting when we were discussing ways to improve student advising...
- Behavior: you shared feedback from your students and suggested a few practical changes to the advising process.
- Impact: Your input helped the team better understand what students need and gave us concrete ideas we can use to improve their experience.
- Critical Feedback Example:
- Situation: During yesterday's team meeting when we were discussing plans for the upcoming event...
- Behavior: you responded to a colleague's idea by immediately pointing out what wouldn't work, without first asking questions or exploring the idea.
- Impact: The room got quiet, and the conversation stalled. Others seemed hesitant to share additional ideas or suggestions.
Make Performance Conversations Routine
Overview
Regular one-on-one conversations are a valuable opportunity to connect, share feedback, and support growth. Use these conversations to check in on progress, recognize accomplishments, discuss challenges, and revisit goals.
Suggestions for effective check-ins:
Shared Ownership: Both the manager and employee should come prepared and take an active role in the conversation.
Create Space for Honest Dialogue: Create a space where employees feel comfortable being honest, asking questions, and sharing concerns without fear of judgment.
Listen and Ask Questions: Ask questions that encourage conversation and help employees reflect. Give them plenty of space to share their thoughts and questions.
Relationship Building: Use check-ins to understand the employee's goals, motivations, strengths, and experiences.
Solutions Focused: When challenges come up, focus on what can be done next and how you can work together to move forward.
Coaching Opportunity: Use the conversation to help employees think through challenges and what next steps they can take to work through the challenge.
Action Items: End with clear next steps, so everyone knows what was discussed and what happens next.
Sample Check-In Questions
- What are your priorities this week?
- What has been challenging for you recently?
- Any interactions you'd like to discuss?
- What can I do to support you? What do you need from me?
When Performance Needs to Improve
Overview
Supporting employees also means having honest conversations when performance is not meeting expectations. Addressing concerns early and respectfully gives employees the best opportunity to understand what is expected and make meaningful improvements. Conversations may include setting expectations and providing regular and ongoing feedback. These conversations and possible formal follow-up require thoughtful planning.
Our HR Partners team provides expert guidance and assistance to supervisors and managers who are preparing to have critical conversations or considering formal performance management. Reach out to your unit's HR Partner for assistance.
Information specific to performance improvement plans and disciplinary action can be found on our Manager Resources page.
Performance Evaluations
Overview
The annual performance evaluation is a chance to pause, reflect, and look ahead. It provides an opportunity to recognize accomplishments, discuss growth and development, and align priorities for the year ahead.
While the annual evaluation is an important milestone, it should build upon conversations that have taken place throughout the year. Employees should have a clear understanding of how they are doing and should not encounter unexpected feedback during the annual review.
Timeline
January - March: Performance Review and Goal Setting
Performance Review for Prior Year: The employee completes their self-evaluation in ePerformance to reflect on their performance during the prior year. The manager reviews the employee’s self-evaluation and writes a narrative evaluation based on the employee’s current position description, including their strengths and overall performance. The employee and manager will meet to discuss the review and then finalize the evaluation in ePerformance
Goal Setting for Current Year: At the conclusion of the performance review, the manager and employee discuss goals for the current year and record them in ePerformance. Both employee and manager can view and comment on the goals throughout the year.
July - August: Mid-Year Checkpoint (Optional)
There is one optional, but highly encouraged, checkpoint during the year when employees and managers may meet to discuss performance to that point and progress towards goals. This conversation can be documented in ePerformance.
December: Review and Finalize Performance Criteria
The Manager and Employee should review the Goals and Competencies in ePerformance to ensure they are still accurate and reflect the employee's current role and priorities. The manager then clicks the Complete button to finalize the criteria and launch employee self-evaluation for the annual performance review.
Resources for completing Performance Evaluation in ePerformance
Writing Effective Employee Reviews
Review Position Description
Key Achievements: Highlight major accomplishments and goals met
Address Core Competencies: Evaluate key skills like communication, teamwork, leadership, and problem solving. Support feedback with observable behaviors
Maintain Balanced Tone: Recognize strengths and contributions. Note growth areas constructively, offering solutions and development opportunities.
Be Clear and Objective: Use evidence-based statements and avoid vague terms.
End with Forward Focus: Set goals for the next review period and encourage continued growth and engagement.
Performance Review Meeting
- Schedule a meeting to discuss the performance review with at least one week’s notice. Managers can share the text of the evaluation with employees within ePerformance by clicking on "Share with Employee."
- Once the manager shares the evaluation with the employee, the employee has the option to add any final comments not previously shared in their self-evaluation within the ePerformance tool.
- For SU employees: Managers should share the evaluation with the employee at least 2 workdays before the meeting. The manager should provide the final review within 5 days after the meeting.
Manager Resources
The above information is meant to be an overview of performance management, not an exhaustive resource. Ongoing skill development and training can help leaders build skills to have effective performance conversations with their team members throughout the year. Consider exploring these resources to further develop your skills.
HR Resources
Your HR support, which may be a central HR Partner or an embedded HR professional within your school, college, or division, is available to help you think through the appropriate approach and provide assistance.
Training Opportunities
How to have effective performance conversations
This session for leaders and managers focuses on building effective feedback practices year-round, and not just in the annual review. We’ll cover the importance of providing continuous, timely feedback and setting clear expectations. You'll learn about skills for delivering feedback effectively, incorporating feedback into regular 1:1 meetings, and following through on performance conversations. We'll also discuss what happens when regular feedback doesn't get the expected results, including an overview of progressive discipline and when to involve HR. Upcoming dates:
Monday, November 9, 2026 | 10:00 a.m. - 11:00 a.m.
Wednesday, November 18, 2026 | 1:30 p.m. - 2:30 p.m.
Tuesday, December 1, 2026 | 10:00 a.m. - 11:00 a.m.
Sign up for an effective performance conversation session
Effective Performance Reviews
Join one of our leader trainings on conducting annual performance evaluations at UVM, presented by a member of our HR Partner team. Upcoming sessions:
Wednesday, December 9, 2026 | 9:00 a.m. - 10:30 a.m.
Thursday, January 14, 2027 | 1:00 p.m. - 2:30 p.m.
Sign up for an effective performance review session
Supervisor Toolkit for Employee Development
Visit the Supervisor Toolkit for Employee Development which provides a wealth of resources around developing yourself and members of your team. Requires UVM NetID login.