ANTH 179: Environmental Anthropology
Professor Luis Vivanco, Spring 2008
Schedule of Readings
READINGS WITH AN (‘R’) NEXT TO THEM WILL BE ON RESERVE. Electronic versions of these articles are available online through Bailey-Howe’s Voyager. A hard copy of every reserve reading will always be available in the Anthropology Department office – 509 Williams Hall, open 8:00am-4:30pm. The reading should be done before the class date under which they are listed. Unless otherwise noted as “Recommended,” all readings are required.
Problem #1: Why is a cultural perspective important for understanding environmental issues?
Mon. Jan. 14: Introduction to the course, instructor’s expectations, requirements, etc.
No reading
Wed. Jan. 16: The Interconnectedness of Biological and Cultural Diversity
Reading: 1. Nabhan, Gary Paul (1997) “Pledging Allegiance to All Sorts of Diversity.” In Cultures of Habitat: On Nature, Culture, and Story. Washington, DC:Counterpoint. pp. 16-29.
Fri. Jan. 18: Defining Culture and Environment
Reading: 1. Ingold, Tim (2000) “Culture, nature, environment: Steps to an Ecology of Life” The Perception of the Environment: Essays in Livelihood, Dwelling, and Skill. London: Routledge. pp. 13-26.
2. Chapter 1, Human Adaptive Strategies.
Mon. Jan. 21: MLK Holiday (no class)
Wed. Jan. 23: Dominant Theoretical Trends in Environmental Anthropology, Part 1
Film: “In Good Hands: Culture and Agriculture in the Lacandon Rainforest”
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 3-26, 40-52, 139-44.
Fri. Jan. 25: Dominant Theoretical Trends in Environmental Anthropology, Part 2
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 257-69, 302-324, 351-4.
Mon. Jan. 28: Putting Culture to the Test: What is “Cultural” about Global Climate
Change? (UVM Focus the Nation Teach-in)
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 407-17.
2. Berry, Wendell. “Solving for Pattern.” Good News of the Twentieth Century, pp. 154-63.
Recommended: Tsing, Anna (2005) “Natural Universals and the Global Scale” Friction: An Ethnography of Global Connection. Princeton: Princeton U. Press.pp. 88-112.
Problem #2: What is the role of environmental adaptation in shaping a people’s lifeways?
Wed. Jan. 30: Adaptation and Human Culture
Film: “India’s Sacred Cow”
Reading: Chapter 2, Human Adaptive Strategies.
Fri. Feb. 1: Adaptation and Modes of Subsistence, Part 1
Reading: 1. Chapters 3-4, Human Adaptive Strategies
Mon. Feb. 4: Adaptation and Modes of Subsistence, Part 2
Reading: 1. Chapter 5, Human Adaptive Strategies
Wed. Feb. 6: Complicating Adaptationism, Part 1: Adaptation in/and/of Complex Systems
Film: “The Goddess and the Computer”
Reading: 1. Chapter 6, Human Adaptive Strategies
[Due in class: Commitment to research topic]
Fri. Feb. 8: Complicating Adaptationism, Part 2: Nature and Culture as Processes
In-class: Quiz #1
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 205-14.
Problem #3: Why are some people more affected by environmental degradation than others?
Mon. Feb. 11: Is it Because of Population Growth?
In class-debate: Resolved: Population growth is the most important reason poor countries experience environmental degradation.
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, begin pp. 73-136.
Wed. Feb. 13: Thinking Critically about Population and Environment
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, finish pp. 73-136.
Fri. Feb. 15: Dilemmas of Development at a Household Scale
Green Revolution Simulation
In-class activity: Green Revolution simulation
Reading: 1. Chapter 8, Human Adaptive Strategies.
Mon. Feb. 18: President’s Day (no class)
Wed. Feb. 20: Political Ecology and The Structure of Capitalism
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 284-301.
[Due in class: Annotated bibliography]
Fri. Feb. 22: Feminist Political Ecology
In-class: Quiz #2
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 27-33, 183-190.
Problem #4: What is the relationship between traditional ecological knowledge and science?
Mon. Feb. 25: Western Epistemologies of Nature and Environment
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 243-5.
2. Williams, Dee (2000) “Representations of Nature on the Mongolian Steppe: An Investigation of Scientific Knowledge Construction.” American Anthropologist 102(3): 503-19.
Wed. Feb. 27: Ethnoecology and/as Situated Knowledge
Film: “Second Nature”
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, 34-9.
2. McGregor, Barbara (2004) “Traditional Ecological Knowledge and Sustainable Development: Towards Coexistence.” In Blaser, Feit, and McRae (eds.) In the Way of Development: Indigenous Peoples, Life Projects, and Sustainable Development. Zed Books, pp. 72-91.
[Due in class: Revised statement of topic and research questions]
Fri. Feb. 29: The Uses (and Abuses) of Ethnoecology
Reading: 1. Brown, Michael (2003) “Ethnobotany Blues,” In Who Owns Native Culture? Cambridge: Harvard University Press, pp. 95-143.
Mon. March 3: Is Ethnoecology “Religious?” Is it “Scientific”?
Reading: 1. Gonzalez, Roberto (2001) “The Conceptual Bases of Zapotec Farming and Foodways” and “Maize has a Soul: Rincón Zapotec Notions of Living Matter.” Zapotec Science: Farming and Food in the Northern Sierra of Oaxaca. Austin: U. Texas Press. pp. 1-31 and 102-129.
Wed. March 5: The Contested Role of Ethnoecology in Environmentalism
In-class: Quiz #3
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 226-36, 367-85.
Fri. March 7: The Debate over Indigenous Ecological Wisdom
In-class debate: Resolved: Ethnoecology is less effective than scientific approaches for managing the environment.
Reading: 1. Mann, Charles (2002) “1491.” Atlantic Monthly.com
[Due in class: Transcript of 1 interview or observation related to your topic]
March 10-14: Spring Recess (no class)
Problem #5: Under what conditions do people take action to defend, protect, or conserve nature?
Mon. March 17: It Depends on Who They Are and How They Think About “Nature”
In-class Activity: Deforestation in Haiti exercise
Reading: 1. Guha, Ramachandra (1997) “Environmentalism of the Poor.” In Fox and Starn (eds.) Between Resistance and Revolution: Cultural Politics and Social Protest. Rutgers U. Press, pp. 17-39.
Wed. March 19: The “Irruption of the Biological” and Other Concerns
Reading: 1. Escobar, Arturo (1997) “Cultural Politics and Biological Diversity: State, Capital, and Social Movements in the Pacific Coast of Colombia.” In
Fox and Starn (eds.) Between Resistance and Revolution: Cultural Politics and Social Protest. Rutgers U. Press, pp. 40-64.
Recommended: The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 270-83.
Fri. March 21: Indigenous People and Environmental Activism
Guest Lecture: Glenn McRae
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, 355-66, 386-89.
Mon. March 24: Principles of Environmental Justice
Reading: 1. Preface and Chapter 1, AlterNatives
Wed. March 26: “It’s Not Just an Indian Issue”
Film: “Keepers of the Water”
Reading: 1. Chapters 2-3, AlterNatives
[Due in class: Rough draft]
Fri. March 28: Discussion of AlterNatives
Reading: 1. Chapters 4-5, AlterNatives
Mon. March 31: Discussion of AlterNatives
Quiz #4: Quiz #4
Reading: 1. Chapters 6-7, AlterNatives
Problem #6: How and why do efforts to formally conserve biodiversity sometimes clash with local communities?
Wed. April 2: The Challenge to Conservationists
In-class debate: Resolved: Mainstream environmental groups abuse indigenous communities.
Reading: 1. Chapin, M. (2004) “The Challenge to Conservationists.” World Watch 17(5): 1-31.
Recommended: The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 237-42.
Fri. April 4: Conservation’s Global Flows
Reading: 1. Chapter 1, Conservation is Our Government Now
Mon. April 7: Locating Maimafu and Crater Mountain
Reading: 1. Chapters 2-3, Conservation is Our Government Now
Wed. April 9: Divergent Goals of Conservation and Development, Part 1
Film: Begin watching “Death by Myth”
Reading: 1. Chapter 4, Conservation is Our Government Now
Recommended: The Environment in Anthropology, 215-25.
Fri. April 11: Divergent Goals of Conservation and Development, Part 2
Film: Finish watching “Death by Myth”
Reading: 1. Chapter 5, Conservation is Our Government Now
[Due in class: Policy/Advocacy/Activism Addendum]
Mon. April 14: Discussion of Conservation is Our Government Now
Reading: 1. Chapter 6, Conservation is Our Government Now
Wed. April 16: Discussion of Conservation is Our Government Now
In-class: Quiz #5
Reading: 1. Chapter 7, Conservation is Our Government Now
Problem #7: Is it possible to have sustainable foodways in our consumer society?
Fri. April 18: Rethinking Foodways and Sustainability
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 191-202, 418-29.
2. McWilliams, J. “Food that Travels Well.” The New York Times 8/6/07.
Mon. April 21: The Opportunities and Costs of an Industrial Agricultural System
Reading: 1. Chapter 7, Human Adaptive Strategies
Wed. April 23: Political Ecology of Biotechnology
Film: “Deconstructing Supper”
Reading: 1. The Environment in Anthropology, pp. 418-29; 443-8.
Recommended: Stone, Glenn Davis (2004) “Biotechnology and Political Ecology of Information in India.” Human Organization 63(2): 127-40.
Fri. April 25: Can “Traditional” Agroecology Feed People on a Large Scale?
Reading: 1. Pretty, Jules (2002) “Food for All” In Agri-Culture: Reconnecting People, Land, and Nature. Earthscan, pp. 78-101.
Mon. April 28: Course Conclusions
In-class: Quiz #6
No reading
Wed. April 30: Course Conclusion
No reading
[Due in class: Final draft]
Wed. May 7: Final Exam (Collaborative Poster Presentations)