most instances above overlap with note on 142b9 or
related notes, but the underlined instances above and below
are not in note on 142b9
146b2 and 184c3 mentioned in note on
146b1-2, which also includes 152d4 and
178e2, but that note also includes
162a1-3, which is not listed here
143a1, 144a6, 150a1, 155d5(seems
to fit here better although it begins new sentence), 164e6,
and 207a5 are found in note on 144a6 and here,
but the following which are
in note on 144a6 are not found here:143a7, 144b9-c1, 144d2,
145d5, 148e3, 166c2, 167a5, 167b1, 167c5, 171d3,175a5,
176b3, 180a3, 180b6, 191c1, 196d11, 197e5, 172b2,
191a1why?
153e3, 168b8, e7, 202e8, 203d7, are in note on 142b9, but not in above list: why?
after question implying negative response, alla = "nay
rather"
2777 after question implying negative response alla = "except"
149e5, 202e8
2778 μηδὲν
ἀλλ’ ἢ 167e2, 202b1,
2781 antecedent statement is positive
2781a antecedent statement is concessive (and positive):
142c3, , , 169b8, 167c5 (hardly
opposed, however, and in spite of the punctuation)
2781b = "and not" 150b7, 150b9, 162a2, 166b8, 168a4,
168b7, 169d10 (McDowell "instead of"), 178d1, 182a7, 182a8,
184d2, 200a8, 209e7 OVERLAPS PERFECTLY WITH NOTE ON
150b7-8 and 9!
2784 introducing new, opposed sentence 145d5 (perhaps more at
home at 2781a), 148c6, 150a1 (following negative, so perhaps
2776 too), 164e6 (following negative, so perhaps 2776 too),
167a5, 167b1 (after negative, so perhaps 2776 too), , 171d3,
171b2 (antecedent statement negative, so perhaps 2776 too),
175a5, 176a5, 177e4 (barely adversative), 178c9 (barely
adversative), 180a3 (after a negative, and so perhaps 2776 too),
180b6 (after negative, so perhaps 2776 too), 187a1, 188a5 (after
neg., so perhaps 2776 too), 189b10, 190e5, 191a1 (after neg., so
2776 too), 191b1 (after a negative, so sort of 2776--it's
definitely a new unit), 196d1, 197e1, 198e7, 203d6, 206c1 (but
hardly opposed at all, really), 209b10 (hardly opposed, just
continuative, more like "and"), 209c4 (hardly opposed, more like
"and")
2784 Z (should be a subpoint of 2784) impatiently interrupting
a previous train of thought: , 148e1(although with the
imperative, perhaps 2784c), 184d6, 185d7, 186a1(
λλὰ
μὴν), 188b7, 188c2, 188e7 (
λλὰ
μὴν), 189a12
143a7 (probably belongs under 2784c)
2784a in replies (often quick/abrupt, decisive): 143b1(could
be at 2784c too), 145c6(decisive), 146c4 (decisive), 148a5 (but
maybe fits at 2781a? doesn't seem to fit at 2784e), 163a2
(or maybe at 2784b), 163e13, 164d4, 165d1, 168e6 (could be at
2784b too?), 169c8, 169d2 (could be at 2784b too), 170c9
(could be 2784Z), 171c9, 181e3, 183d10, 187a7(λλὰ
μὴν), 188b6, 190d3, 195e5, 198e6, 199a3, 200c6,
201d6, 207d2, 208a4 (contrast the negative here with the
positive of 207d2: assent v. no assent)
2784b assent: 151d7(Ἀλλὰ
μέντοι:
nay, but under 2786), 153d6, 157d9, 162b4, 162b8, 163a2 (or
maybe at 2784a) (some of those listed above under "replies"
should perhaps be here).