Fortson Greek exercises: answers and reasoning
quotes are all from Wiktionary unless otherwise noted.
- 2.
- a. *h1le-h1ludh- 'come'
- a reduplicated perfect stem: interesting that the
laryngeal AND the liquid reduplicate.
- the liquids /l/ stay the same
- the *dh devoices to become th
- word-final consonants except n and s drop away, but this
is not word-final: it's just stem-final.
- laryngeals before a consonant : 12.24 indicates that they
become one of three vowels *h1> *e , *h2> a,
and *h3 > o , so here *h1l > el
- the e vowel in the middle: *h1l> e, so it becomes
ele-eluth, which contracts to long ē
- > Greek ἐλήλῠθᾰ elḗlutha
- (the little half-moons over vowels simply indicate that
the vowels are short)
- Beekes:
“perf. εἰλήλουθα ('Attic reduplication' from *
h1le-h1loudh-, with metrical lengthening), ptc. ἐ(ι)ληλουθώς
(epic), ἐλήλυθα (post-Hom.)”
- Note that there are two ways to spell this stem out:
with an ou and just a u.
- b. *deh3-rom 'gift'
- > δῶρον
- *eh3 colors to *oh3, the laryngeal drops out, and
compensatory lengthening occurs, so we are left with ō (ω)
- d and r stay the same.
- 12.20 says final *m became n
- c. *h2woideh2 'song'
- > ἀοιδή aoidā , which turned into Attic
ᾠδή ōidḗ (the iota is written below the line in Greek
because later Greek did not pronounce it)
- 12.24 says *h2 > a
- w, represented by digamma, disappears in most Greek
dialects.
- *oi remains
- *d remains
- *eh2 colors to ah2, then *h2 drops out and compensatory
lengthening occurs, which leaves ā (η)
- d. *gwelbhus 'womb'
-
"From Proto-Indo-European
*gʷelbʰ-
(“womb”).
Cognate with Sanskrit गर्भ(garbha)."
Remember this one from the Indic chapter?
- *gwe > de
- *l remains
- *bh devoices to ph (12.10: devoicing of voiced aspirates)
- *u stays
- word-final *s stays
- > δελφυς delphús
- e. *tn̥tos 'stretched'
- f. *bhn̥g̑hus
'thick'
- Attic πῆχυς pēkhus
- Aeolic πᾶχῠς
(pâkhus)
- "From
Proto-Hellenic *pā́kʰus, from Proto-Indo-European
*bʰeh₂ǵʰus. Cognates include Sanskrit बाहु (bāhu, “arm”),
Old Persian 𐎲𐎠𐏀𐎢 (bāzu) (Persian بازو (bâzu)) and Old
English bōg (English bough)."
- *g̑h
> *gh (palatal stops merge into plain velars in centum
languages)
- *bh > ph and *gh > kh devoicing of voiced aspirates)
- *us stays
- g. *h2weh1-ti
- 12.24 says *h2 > a
- w, represented by digamma, disappears in most Greek
dialects.
- *eh1 does not color, but laryngeal drops out with
compensatory lengthening > ē (η)
- *ti stays
- > ἄϝητι a(w)ēti "it blows"
- h. *h2i-h2eus-oh2 'I stay the night'
- > Greek ἰαύω iaúō
- *h2i- > i (in my Greek dictionary, that's a short i:
not sure why no compensatory lengthening, but it doesn't
occur in every environment, and this is not one that I can
find with my current resources)
- *h2e colors to a, laryngeal drops, and the a becomes long,
which makes this a long diphthon.
- *oh2 > ō (ω) is the expected outcome of the PIE
thematic 1st sg. present active ending (12.36).
- i. *h2enh1mos 'wind'
- " Ancient Greek ἄνεμος (ánemos), Proto-Indo-European
*h₂enh₁mos, a nominal derivative of *h₂enh₁- (“breathe”)"
- *h2e colors to a, but no compensatory lengthening: it is a
short a in the Greek dictionary
- *h1 > e
- *mos stays
- j. *bheidhoh2 'I trust'
- devoicing of aspirates > *pheithoh2
- grassmans law dissimilates first aspirate > *peithoh2
- laryngeal drops out and lengthens > *peithō (πεἰθω)
- k. *newos 'new'
- *w drops out in most dialects
- > neos νέος
- "From Proto-Hellenic *néwos (compare Mycenaean Greek
(ne-wo)), from Proto-Indo-European *néwos. Cognates include
Old English nīwe (English new), Latin novus, Sanskrit नव
(náva), and Avestan 𐬥𐬀𐬎𐬎𐬀 (nauua)."
- l. *n̥gwēn 'gland'
- > Greek ἀδήν adḗn, genitive ἀδένος adénos
- Wiktionary: "Beekes suggests Proto-Indo-European
*h₁engʷḗn, because *h₁n̥gʷ-ḗn would
produce *endḗn
by Rix's Law (PIE *HR̥C > Proto-Hellenic *e/a/oRC),
and rejects the connection with Latin inguen (“groin”) and
Old Norse økkvenn
(“thick, clodded”)."
- "De Vaan prefers to derive it from Proto-Indo-European
*n̥gʷḗn (“the naked one”),
from *negʷ-
(“naked”),
preserving the connection with Latin inguen but excluding the Germanic
forms."
- *n̥ syllabic nasal > a
- *gwē > dē (12.15 covers the outcome of the labiovelars,
which either go dental or labial depending on whether the
accompanying vowel is front or back)
- *n consonant in final position stays
- 3. Some good reasons to think that the Indic and the Greek
occurrences of Grassman's law, which says that the first of two
aspirated consonants in a word will de-aspirate, include:
- No other languages show this law: if it were a change that
happened already in PIE, we would expect other languages to
show it. It may, however, still be an "areal" change, which
means that somehow the Indic and the Greek are connected by
being in the same "area." But the Indic and the Greek
languages are separated by a vast distance, so it's hard to
imagine or see how this could be an areal change.
- The Greek devoicing of the aspirates must have occurred
before Grassman changes occurred in Greek, because of a form
like tithemi (compare Sanskrit dadhami). If
the change had occurred in PIE, Greek would be dithemi.
- 4. I think this is asking us to describe what we see in terms
of a sound change law, and take it on faith that changes similar
to this occurred regularly in Greek.
- One way to account for it would be a law that says that the
labiovelar kw became a labial b, as expected according to
12.15, but then the labial b assimilated to the following
nasal and become nasal mm or mn, but the aspirated *gwh, which
became a ph as expected according to 12.15, but the aspiration
made it not assimilate to nasals, so it remained phn.
- There may be other ways to formulate it.