1. numbered steps clearly and accurately labeled and cross-references are accurate

______/10 points

2. every premise or conclusion has a Stephanus page, letter, and number and is accurate

______/10 points

3. structure is a clearly labeled argument (what is a premise and what is a conclusion is clear and works well)

______/15 points

4. precise careful wording that makes things clear as crystal and is not wordy at all

______/15 points

5. everything accurately represents what Plato says

6. meta-comments are present and briefly identify problems/alternatives/assumptions/argument structure/etc.

8. overall coverage and quality of content: is it complete? does it do what was assigned? does it include all the important things? is there some thing that needs improvement not covered above?

______/15 points