ToC Search About SiteMap Glossary

The Eugenics Survey in Vermont: Studies

The Women at the Rutland Reformatory 1929
("Miss Ross' Girls")

"Two problems connected with the care of the feeble-minded have been noted...The first is the care of the low-grade feeble-minded. . .The other problem is that of the defective delinquent, both adult and juvenile. . .The delinquent feeble-minded woman is even a worse social problem. While in the Reformatory at Rutland she is easily managed and happy; when discharged at the end of her sentence she returnes to the community quite unable to meet its requirements because mentally she is only a little girl. Usually she becomes a sex offender and her neglected children either legitimate or illegitimate further tax the social resources of the state."
Rural Vermont: A Program for the Future, "Care of the Handicapped"

Social workers and philanthropists took a special interest in poor women in repeated trouble with the law and lamented the fate of their children. Since 1916, the Vermont Conference of Social Work and the Vermont Children's Aid Society had campaigned for expanded programs of child support and family case work. Lena Ross, a probation officer and field worker for the State Board of Charities and Probation, had initiated a rehabilitation program for female delinquents at the Women's Reformatory at Rutland in 1921, one that was celebrated as a demonstration the spirit of charity, self-sufficiency, and resourcefulness of Vermonters. In 1929, at the request of Superintendent Lena Ross, Eugenics Survey field investigator Martha Wadman conducted IQ tests of the women inmates of the Rutland Reformatory for the Vermont Commission on Country Life Committee on the Handicapped.

The documents included here show different portraits of the women inmates at the Rutland Reformatory. Sara Cleghorn's and Dorothy Canfield's article, "Miss Ross' Girls," does not betray Lena Ross' confidential concerns and minimizes the problems studied by Martha Wadman.  Lillian Ainsworth's addendum to "Miss Ross' Girls," "On the Side," celebrates the community support of delinquent women with children, yet contrasts with her stong support for eugenics in her 1941 report to the Vermont Department of Public Welfare, "Vermont's Feeble-minded Problem." The "Report of the Survey," by an unidentified social worker, presents a rebuttal to Wadman's report, illustrating the ambivalence often expressed among social workers over the validity of IQ tests and their alleged basis in heredity. Martha Wadman's notes on the psychometric tests of the women suggest the influence of personal impressions on the evaluation of intelligence. In its final report, the Eugenics Survey did not discuss sterilization of "feebleminded" women, yet left the door open for either eugenic or social interpretations and solutions.


Return to: Beginning of this section: Studies
Return to: Vermont Survey Table of Contents