NEGATIVE COUNTERPLANS i04
STATES/FEDERALISM COUNTERPLAN
NEGATIVE COUNTERPLAN – STATES SHELL
FEDERALISM IS ALIVE AND WELL AS STATES NOW HAVE POWER
THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT IS THE WRONG AGENT TO PROTECT PRIVACY
STATE GOVERNMENTS ARE THE RIGHT AGENTS TO PROTECT PRIVACY
OTHER NATIONS MODEL USA ON FEDERALISM
FEDERALISM CREATES PEACE AND STABILITY
FEDERALISM PROTECTS MINORITIES FROM MAJORITIES
FEDERALISM SUSTAINS ECONOMIC PROSPERITY
FEDERALISM PROTECTS INDIVIDUAL RIGHTS
ANSWERS TO STATES/FEDERALISM COUNTERPLAN
THE FEDERALIST IDEOLOGY IS TOO VAGUE
PERMUTATION – FEDERAL PLAN CAN SET A BASELINE AND STATES CAN GO BEYOND IT
NOT UNIQUE – STATES RIGHTS FEDERALISM IS DEAD ALREADY
STATES WILL DO A BAD JOB AT PROTECTING PRIVACY
WE NEED ONE NATIONAL PRIVACY STANDARD, NOT 5O DIFFERENT ONES
STATE BY STATE APPROACH WILL DESTROY E-COMMERCE
FEDERAL LAW IS NEEDED FOR MEDICAL PRIVACY
FEDERAL LAW IS NEEDED FOR DNA DATABASES
AFFIRMATIVE – COURT COUNTERPLAN
COURT COUNTERPLAN IS AN UNACCEPTABLE APPROACH TO PRIVACY PROTECTION
COMMUNITARIANISM COUNTERPLAN
COMMUNITARIANISM COUNTERPLAN SHELL
COMMUNITARIANISM IS A PROCESS, NOT A PRE-DETERMINED DOGMA
COMMUNITARIANISM BREAKS THE RULES OF EXISTING DOGMATIC THINKING
COMMUNITARIANISM OPPOSES SOCIAL SUBORDINATION, NOT DISCRIMINATION
COMMUNITARIANISM WORKS AT ALL LEVELS OF GOVERNMENT
BY FOCUSING ON THE RIGHTS OF THE INDIVIDUAL THE PLAN WORKS AGAINST COMMUNITARIANISM
NET BENEFIT – THE COUNTERPLAN TRADES OFF PRIVACY TO GAIN NET SOCIAL BENEFIT
COMMUNITARIANISM DOES NOT COMMIT ITSELF TO PRIVACY AS THE AFFIRMATIVE PLAN DOES
NET BENEFIT – FURTHER PRIVACY PROMOTION DAMAGES SOCIETY
AFFIRMATIVE CLAIMS TO PROTECT RIGHTS IS INCOMPATIBLE WITH COMMUNITARIANISM
SPECIFIC CONCEPTS AFFIRMATIVE EMBRACES ARE INCOMPATIBLE WITH COMMUNITARIANISM
MEDICAL RECORDS – COUNTERPLAN WILL PROTECT MEDICAL RESEARCH BENEFITS
MEDICAL RECORDS – COUNTERPLAN WILL END UP PROTECTING PRIVACY WITHOUT BEING A PRIVACY POLICY
DATA PRIVACY & ENCRYPTION & SEARCH-SEIZURE
ETZIONI’S COMMUNITARIAN PRIVACY CALCULUS SOLVES
COMMUNITARIAN IDEAS SOLVE PROBLEMS
COMMUNITARIANISM IS BUILDING A POWERFUL SOCIAL MOVEMENT
COMMUNITARIANISM PRACTICE WILL BUILD STRONGER COMMUNITIES
COMMUNITARIANISM IS A PROCESS WHICH CREATES DEMOCRACY AND THE BEST DECISIONS ON ISSUES
COMMUNITARIANISM IS APPLICABLE UP AND DOWN THE POLITICAL SCALE
ADVANTAGES OF COMMUNITARIANISM
AVOID DOMINATION AND IMPOVERISHMENT
SPECIFIC PROGRAMS OF COMMUNITARIANISM
COUNTERPLAN FREE MARKET
FREE MARKET SELF-REGULATION IS THE BEST POLICY SYSTEM FOR INFORMATION
FREE MARKET WILL BEST PROTECT PRIVACY
NET BENEFITS – LESS GOVERNMENT INVOLVEMENT THE BETTER
MUTUALLY EXCLUSIVE – FREE MARKET AND PRIVACY PROTECTION
NO PERMUTATION – FREE MARKET MUST OPERATE WITHOUT GOVERNMENT
SOLVENCY – INTERNET BUSINESSES ARE MOVING TO PROTECT PRIVACY BECAUSE OF MARKET FORCES
NO PERMUTATION OR CO-OPTATION – GOVERNMENT MUST HAVE NO ROLE IN ORDER TO HAVE REAL SELF-REGULATION
INDIVIDUALS CAN AND WILL PROTECT THEIR OWN PRIVACY IF THEY DESIRE
INDIVIDUALS CAN USE PRIVACY ENHANCING TECHNOLOGIES (P.E.T.S)
INDIVIDUALS CAN USE ENCRYPTION TO PROTECT THEIR PRIVACY
ENCRYPTION IS A WORKABLE FORM OF PRIVACY PROTECTION
BLIND SIGNATURE IS A WORKABLE FORM OF PRIVACY PROTECTION
INDIVIDUAL ACTION IN A FREE MARKET IS THE BEST WAY TO PROTECT PRIVACY
LIBERTARIANISM IS THE IDEOLOGY BEHIND THE FREE MARKET
ATTACKS ON LIBERTARIANISM ARE UNTRUE
ANSWERS TO FREE MARKET COUNTERPLAN
THE FREE MARKET WILL NOT SOLVE FOR PRIVACY
INDIVIDUAL ACTION WITH P.E.T.S WILL FAIL
GOVERNMENT INVOLVEMENT IS NEEDED TO RESTRAIN THE MAJORITY
ENCRYPTION WILL NOT BE SUFFICIENT
FREE MARKET WILL NOT WORK FOR MEDICAL INFORMATION