University of Vermont Historic Preservation Program

HP 5201 - History on the Land

Robert McCullough

Links:

Return to Homepage

Buildings, Structures, Places and People

 



HISTORY ON THE LAND

Course Syllabus - Spring 2024


REQUIRED READINGS.  Required readings will be assigned from the following books, which should be purchased if possible.  Town Planning in Frontier America is now out of print, and a copy is on reserve at Bailey Howe Library and in Wheeler House.  In addition, you may be able to find used copies via the internet. 

1.     William Cronin, Changes in the Land. Indians, Colonists, and the Ecology of New England.
2.     Chester Liebs, Main Street to Miracle Mile. American Roadside Architecture.
3.     John Reps, Town Planning in Frontier America. (Out of Print- Reserve)
4.    
Witold Rybczynski, Last Harvest. How a Cornfield Became New Daleville.
5.    
John Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 1580 to 1845.
6.    
John Stilgoe, Outside Lies Magic. Regaining History and Awareness in Everyday Places.
7.    
Sam Bass Warner, Streetcar Suburbs. The Process of Growth in Boston (1870-1900).

Reading assignments have also been selected from the following, which are available for reserve reading in the Wheeler House library.

1.    
Zane Miller and Patricia M. Melvin, The Urbanization of Modern America. A Brief History.  Note: this book is out of print but various editions may be available from the internet.  Page numbers may not conform to the assigned numbers, but the general content should be apparent.
2.    
John Stilgoe, Metropolitan Corridor. Railroads and the American Scene.

            SUPPLEMENTAL READINGS.  Supplemental readings have been identified for each class and a separate bibliography will be distributed.  These readings are not required but are offered as optional sources that provide greater depth regarding their respective topics or that were used extensively in the preparation of class lectures.  They are also beginning points for research regarding your paper topics.  
 

CLASS SCHEDULE


Tuesday, January 16th: 
Introduction: History on the Land

Required:
1. Stilgoe, Outside Lies Magic, 1-58
.
2. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 3-43
.


Thursday, January 18th: 
Patterns of Settlement: English Colonial Town Plans.

Required:                                   
1. Reps, Town Planning in Frontier America, 73-180.
2. Stilgoe, Outside Lies Magic, 59-69.

Supplemental:
1. Paul Zucker,
Town and Square from the Agora to the Village Green.
2.
Anthony N. Garvan, Architecture and Town Planning in Colonial Connecticut.

Tuesday,  January 23rd: Transport:  Colonial Roads to Good Roads and the Trails and Turnpikes Between

Required:
1. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 107-115,129-134.

2. Reps, Town Planning in Frontier America, 181-210.

Supplemental:
1. Frederick Wood, The Turnpikes of New England and Evolution of the Same Through New England, Virginia, and Maryland.
2. Karl Raitz, ed., The National Road.


Thursday, January 25th:  Transport: Canals

Required:

1. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 115-134.

2. Reps, Town Planning in Frontier America, 211-237.

Supplemental:
1. Patricia Anderson,  The Course of Empire. The Erie Canal and t
he New York Landscape, 1825-1875.
2.  Robert J. Kapsch,  Canals.

Tuesday, January 30th:  Transport: Railroads.  OUTLINE DUE

Required:

1. Stilgoe, Metropolitan Corridor, 21-132.

2. Reps, Town Planning in Frontier America, 238-263.
 

Supplemental
:

1. Carl Condit, The Port of New York. A History of the Rail and
Terminal System from the Beginning to Pennsylvania Station.

Thursday, February 1st:  Agriculture: Landscapes and Barns

Required:
1. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 135-170.

2. Cronin, Changes in the Land, 1-15.

Supplemental:
1. Thomas Hubka, Big House, Little House, Back House, Barn.
  The Connected Farm Buildings of New England.
2. Howard S. Russell, A Long Deep Furrow: Three Centuries of
Farming in New England.


Tuesday: February 6th:  Urban and Community Agriculture: Commercial Greenhouses


Required:

1. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 170-208.

2. Cronin, Changes in the Land, 127-156.

Supplemental:
1. John Auwaerter, "Factories of Glass: Development of the
Modern Commercial Greenhouse, 1880-1930."
2. John Hix, The Glass House.


Thursday, February 8th: Commercial and Industrial Buildings: Turning Points in Evolution of Size, Structure and Materials, Part 1:  Brick Bearing Walls, Trusses and Arches, and I-Beams.

Required:
1. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 265-309

Supplemental:
1. Cecil Elliott, Technics and Architecture. The Development of Materials and Systems for Buildings.
2. H. Ward Jandl, ed., The Technology of Historic American Buildings.
3.
Carl Condit, American Building Art. The Nineteenth Century (Vol. 1) and The Twentieth Century (Vol. 2).

Tuesday,  February 13th:  Commercial and Industrial Buildings:  Turning Points in Evolution of Size, Structure and Materials,  Part 2:  Plate Glass, Terra Cotta, and Reinforced Concrete

 Required:
1. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 309-324.

 Supplemental:
1. Carl Condit, American Building Art. The Nineteenth Century (Vol. 1) and The Twentieth Century (Vol. 2).

 
Thursday, February 15th:  Power: Wind

Required:
1. 
Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 88-99
2. 
Miller & Melvin, Urbanization of Modern America, 3-43

Supplemental:
1. Lindsay Baker, A Field Guide to American Windmills.

Tuesday, February 20th  Power: Direct Drive Water

Required:
1. Miller & Melvin, Urbanization of Modern America, 47-104.

Supplemental:
1. Louis Hunter, Water Power - Steam Power. A History of Industrial Power in the United States, 1780-1930.  2 vols.
2. Theodore Steinberg, Nature Incorporated.  Industrialization and
the Waters of New England.


Thursday, February 22nd:  Power: Steam.  ASSIGNMENT PART ONE DUE

Required:
1.  Miller & Melvin, Urbanization of Modern America, 105-124.

2.  Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 339-346.


Supplemental
1.
Louis Hunter, Water Power - Steam Power. A History of Industrial Power in the United States, 1780-1930.  2 vols.


Tuesday, February 27th:  Power: Coal-Fired, Steam-Generated Electricity and Hydro-Electricity

Required:
1. Miller & Melvin, Urbanization of Modern America, 125-174 


Thursday, Februrary 29th:  Factory    
 

Required:
1. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 324-337.

Supplemental:
1. Grant Hildebrand, Designing for Industry. The Architecture of Albert Kahn.  

   

Tuesday, March 5th.  Town Meeting Day Recess. No Scheduled Class. Voluntary Session.  Select a Topic of Interest


Thursday, March 7th:  MID-TERM EXAMINATION 

 

Thursday, March 12th:  Spring Recess - No Class

Thursday, March 14th: Spring Recess - No Class  

   

Tuesday, March 19th:  Iron

Required:
1.  Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 99-107.


Thursday, March 21st:  Urbanity                  

Required:
1. Miller & Melvin, Urbanization of Modern America, 175-252.

2. Warner, Streetcar Suburbs, 1-34.

 Supplemental:
1. David Ward, Cities and Immigrants: A Geography of Change in
19th Century America.
2. Roger Trancik, Finding Lost Space. Theories of Urban Design.

Tuesday, March 26th:  Transit: Streetcars and Inter-UIrbans

Required:
1. Warner, Streetcar Suburbs, 35-116

Thursday, March 28th: Transit: Rapid

Required:
1. Warner, Streetcar Suburbs, 117-166.


Supplemental:

1. Robert C. Reed, The New York Elevated
.
2. Michael W. Brooks, Subway City. Riding the Trains, Reading 
New York.


Tuesday, April 2nd: Community: By Plan

Required:
1. Reps, Town Planning in Frontier America, 264-295.

2. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 209-231.

3. Stilgoe, Outside Lies Magic, 131-155.
4. Ryczynksi, Last Harvest, 1-97.

Supplemental:
1. Clarence Stein, Toward New Towns for America.

 
Thursday, April 4th: Community: By Park.  Part 1: Public Squares, Garden Cemeteries, Pleasure Grounds, and Park Ways.                

Required:
1. Cronin, Changes in the Land, 19-81.
2. Rybczynski, Last Harvest, 101-183.

Supplemental:
1. Galen Cranz, The Politics of Park Design. A History of Urban Parks in America.
2.
Witold Rbyczynski, A Clearing in the Distance. Frederick Law Olmsted and America in the 19th Century

Tuesday, April 9th: Community: By Park.  Part 2: Progressivism and Municipal Reform Parks - City Beautiful Parks, Neighborhood Parks, Playgrounds, and School Parks; Progressivism and Conservation Era Parks - Forest Parks and Prairie Parks; Recreation Facilities; Pocket Parks; and Amusement Parks,

Required:
1. Stilgoe, Outside Lies Magic, 103-129.
2. Rybczynski, Last Harvest, 187-201.

Supplemental:
1. Leonard K. Eaton, Landscape Artist in America. The Life and
Work of Jens Jensen.
 

Thursday, April 11th: Community: By Forest

Required:
1. Cronin, Changes in the Land, 82-126.
 

Supplemental
:

1. Robert McCullough, Landscape of Community. A History of
Communal Forests in New England.

Tuesday, April 16th:  Community: By Footpath

Required:
1. Cronin, Changes in the Land, 159-170.

Supplemental:
1. Laura and Guy Waterman, Forest and Crag.


Thursday, April 18th:  Awheel: Parks, Parkways and Paths for Bicycles

Required:
1. Stilgoe, Common Landscape of America, 231-264.

Supplemental:
1. Charles Little, Greenways for America.



Tuesday, April 23rd: Roads for the Automobile. 
ASSIGNMENT PART TWO DUE 

Required:
1. Liebs, Main Street to Miracle Mile, 1-151.
2. Stilgoe, Outside Lies Magic, 89-101 & 157-178.

Supplemental:
1. Bruce E. Seely, Building the American Highway System. Engineers as Policy Makers.
2. James J. Fink, The Car Culture.


Thursday, April 25th: Roadside:  Fast Food

Required
:
1. Liebs, Main Street to Miracle Mile, 153-227.

Supplemental:
1. Richard Horowitz, The Strip: An American Place.

2. John Jakle and Keith Sculle.  Fast Food. Road Restaurants and
the Automobile Age.

Tuesday,  April 30th:  Roadside: Motel

Required:
1.  Stilgoe, Outside Lies Magic, 71-88, 179-187.

Supplemental:
1. Warren Belasco, Americans on the Road. From Auto Camp to Motel.
2. John Jakle and Keith Sculle.  The Motel in America
.
                                 

Thursday, May 2nd: Escape. 


Thursday, May 11th:   FINAL EXAMINATION: 4:30 to 
7:15 P.M., 402 Williams Hall

  

COURSE INFORMATION

            ASSIGNMENTS.  Students will be asked to prepare a written paper divided into two parts, each part due separately.  The paper will be based on a selected topic that involves any feature of the cultural landscape, such as a building, structure, site, transportation corridor, or designed landscape.  The paper will combine the use of periodical literature and trade journals with field study.  A description of the assignment will be provided.  In final form, the two segments should be typed, and each should be approximately one thousand (1500) words long.  The due dates for a one-page outline of the topic and periodical literature selected, time-spans included, and for the first and second segments are identified in the course schedule.  Students are welcome to submit drafts of their papers in advance of the deadlines.  In addition to those two papers, graduate students are also required to research the life of any historical figure in Vermont who made significant contributions to any aspect of the built or cultural environment in this state, during any period, and to prepare a paper four pages in length, double spaced, providing a biographical sketch of that individual and analyzing his or her important works.  Research should rely on digitized newspapers and archival resources.  

            ATTENDANCE.  Class attendance is required, and the instructor must be notified regarding any absences (See grading below) 

            BIBLIOGRAPHY.  A bibliography of readings for further study on each of the lecture topics will also be posted on the instructor's web page.  This list should be considered as a beginning point for research concerning the topics identified and should be consulted during selection and preparation of the written assignment.

            EXAMINATIONS & GRADING.  Preliminary and final examinations will be based on assigned readings, class presentations, and discussion.  The dates of these examinations are noted on the schedule.  The course grade will be determined as follows: preliminary, 30%, final exam 30%, paper, 30%, attendance and class participation, 10%.

            FIELD TRIP / EXTRA SESSIONS.  A field trip may be scheduled depending on interest and available time.  Extra presentations may be offered in the evening depending upon student interest.  Available topics include Spanish and French patterns of town planning; urban and community agriculture; and the fossil fuel industry.  Others can be developed as desired.  Students can select convenient dates, with at least one week’s prior notice.    

            IMPORTANT PLACES, DATES, AND PERSONS.  Each student will receive a list of important places, dates, persons, etc., mentioned in the lectures.  These are arranged by lecture topic and provide a skeleton outline of the course.  Students should review these lists before class.

OFFICE HOURS.  Office hours will be announced, but other arrangements are possible as required 

THEMATIC OVERVIEW.  The course seeks to provide students with a basic understanding of the historical document that is our cultural environment, whether built or natural.  The subject is vastly complex, and the course is not intended to provide a comprehensive study of any one aspect of the landscape.  In truth, any of the topics (and many of the sub-topics) appearing on the syllabus could be developed into an entire course.  Nevertheless, the syllabus does provide a skeleton that suggests the essential reasons why our landscape appears as it does.  With fundamental understanding, students will be able to read this historic document, to absorb some of the information that it holds, and to explore other segments more deeply without losing sight of the basic structure.  Several themes will be traced throughout.

1.  The discipline of historic preservation seeks to identify and preserve those parts of our physical heritage that hold valuable information about our culture.  Evaluating historic significance -- the process of selecting those monuments worthy of preservation -- is fundamental, and the course will probe the means by which we make this assessment.  In short, what are the economic, social, technological, political, aesthetic, and intellectual contributions that any given part of our physical heritage makes?

            2.  At the same time, we should all be able to recognize and understand the picture puzzle that is our cultural landscape without resorting to structured analysis of historic significance.  Hopefully this will lead to a stronger understanding of American culture and a deeper appreciation of all that surrounds us.

            3.  Historic preservation's emphasis on the built environment has sometimes resulted in neglect of the natural environment and its culturally assisted evolution.  The unfortunate result is that alliances with other disciplines that pursue goals common to those of historic preservation have failed to materialize.  The course will make strong efforts to connect the two.

            4.  The study of methods for reading the landscape is as important as learning about the history that exists if only we know where to look. The course will seek to develop both goals.

            5.  The study of landscape history is one of examining overlapping layers on the face of the land.  Those layers can be confined to a small area and be readily visible, for example a building with clearly defined alterations added over the years.  Alternatively, the layers can be complex and difficult to separate, as in urban areas where human existence has forced sweeping change over the centuries.