Classics 158 (Greco-Roman
Politics)
Cross-listed with Philosophy
195 and Political
Science 195
Lafayette 102
MWF 3:35-4:25
Syllabus
Professor Jacques A. Bailly
Classics Dept.
481 Main St., Room 300
656-0993
jacques.bailly@zoo.uvm.edu
This syllabus is posted on the web at:
http://www.uvm.edu/~jbailly/courses/clas158/. The website syllabus is the
official syllabus. Any paper copy which you or I print out is
not the official syllabus. I encourage you to bookmark the site on your
computers and to refer to it rather than to a paper copy so that you
are aware of any changes that are made during the course of the
semester.
Attendance: Required. See below.
Texts:
Required:
- Aristotle Politics.
- Plato Republic.
- Plato Protagoras.
- Plato Gorgias.
- Sophocles Antigone.
- Thucydides on Justice Power,
and Human Nature, translated by Paul Woodruff, published by
Hackett Publishing.
Grades: 91-100%=A, 81-90%=B,
71-80%=C, 61-70%=D, 60% or lower fails.
Plus and minus will be given for the top three and bottom three points
of each range respectively.
Graded Elements of this Course:
Letters: 20%
Document: 20%
Final Paper: 20%
Midterm and Final: 15% each.
Questions and Quotations: 10%
My estimate of your engagement may improve (or hurt) your grade by up
to 10% (the default is that it will not affect your grade). Evidence of
such engagement includes attendance, participation
in class, contacts outside of class, enthusiasm, and attitude. In other
words, it includes whether or not it is obvious to me that you are
engaged (absence, even if unavoidable, necessarily hampers engagement).
Graded Assignments
Final and Midterm
1. Essay Portion. See below under "written assignments."
2. Factual Matters. You will be asked to know certain factual matters
on the midterm and final. These things will be posted on the web
beforehand.
Questions and Quotations
Every day at the start of class, you must hand in a sheet of
paper with
a question about class material or a written-out quotation from our
readings that
interested you. These will double as attendance evidence, and so none
will be accepted outside of class or by proxy. Please do not ask for
exceptions. I will drop three of them. I will not return them or
comment on them. I may use them to provoke class discussion, as exam
questions, to assess your engagement with the class, and/or to assess
how the course is working.
Written assignments
1. Letters: Every third week, you will
write one letter and bring 3 copies of it to class: give one copy
apiece to 2
classmates and to me. The letter should be 2-3 pages long and should be
highly relevant to the material we are discussing in class. Once the
first letters have been written, a subsequent letter should in part
react to previous letters. A letter should be correct in all the
mechanical aspects of writing such as spelling, punctuation, writing,
word choice, structure, etc. There are no particular requirements in
terms of topics for these letters. One goal of this exercise is to get
to know your classmates in an academic setting and to forge a community
conversation.
GRADING NOTES THAT APPLY (SEE BELOW): A, C
2. A document for use next time I teach the class (i.e. include
whatever you think is most important and interesting for students of
Greco-Roman political thought). The format may be outline, essay, or
whatever you would find most appropriate and helpful as a student (no
powerpoint presentations, however): length may vary depending on the
format you choose (a 5-6 page essay is what I have in mind, so aim for
the equivalent of that). Use of secondary sources is optional, but
recommended. There is no need to go beyond what we read and what was
presented in class, however.
Topics: any of the material from class which we read in UNIT ONE (see
schedule).
Due the 6th of OCTOBER.
GRADING NOTES THAT APPLY (SEE BELOW): A, B
3. Essays: For the midterm and final, you will write 2 short essays (3
pages) on assigned topics. The topics will be announced beforehand, and
you will bring the COMPLETED typed essays with you to the midterm and
final and hand them in with the midterm and final.
GRADING NOTES THAT APPLY (SEE BELOW): A, B
4. Final Paper: One final paper 5-10 pages in length. The paper will
ideally incorporate revised portions of your essays, summary and
letters. In other words, it should grow out of your other writing for
the class.
Late papers will not be accepted
and the
recorded grade will be 0%. It is to be on a topic of your
choosing. The parameters are:
• You should choose a topic before
Thanksgiving break. I am happy to help you with choosing a topic or I
can
suggest one.
• You should identify your
primary ancient sources as well as
several modern secondary sources before Thanksgiving break.
• Explanation of Primary Ancient
Sources must be central to your paper.
• It is to be a research paper,
which means that it will use scholarly secondary sources in a
significant way.
• At least once while writing it
you must use the writing
center OR some other qualified person as a reader (be aware that tutors
are not proofreaders: they will help with other aspects). The reader's
signed summary of your activities should be handed in with the paper.
Be aware that it is very difficult to get a walk-in session with a
writing tutor at the end of the semester. Plan ahead.
GRADING NOTES THAT APPLY (SEE BELOW):
A, B
Revision: You are encouraged to
revise your work for any reason: I will gladly regrade any revision you
submit. The new grade will fully replace the old grade. Historically, I
find that few people take me up on this, but I encourage you to do so.
Drafts: I love to read drafts and help you improve your ideas and
writings. But you must plan ahead: I can't read 20 drafts the hour
before class. If you do get me a draft ahead of time, that will
positively affect my attitude towards your final product.
Student Writing Center: You are highly encouraged to use the writing
center to help you in your writing process. Ask them to send me a
record of the visit and you will receive much good will as I grade the
assignment.
Grading Notes
A.
Must be in good English
suitable for college-level writing assignments (i.e. VERY FEW mistakes
in writing mechanics: less than 2 per typed page). If they are not at
that level, you will be docked a grade for poor quality product. You
may rewrite the assignment to redeem yourself, provided there is time
to do so (i.e. the deadline for all rewrites is the last day of
classes).
B. Must be a well thought out
and
well-structured effort that center around a central topic and reach
some significant conclusion about it. In other words, your first draft
will probably not be sufficient to pass. This should be formal writing:
they should not be informal
in any way (i.e. write it as if it were to be published in a newspaper:
no chatty speech or slang). I place particular value on being concise,
precise, and careful. This assignment will be graded in
the traditional manner as a piece of formal prose.
C. The letters may be
exploratory and tentative: in other words, the content will not be
graded with an eye towards assessing mastery. They will be graded with
an eye toward encouraging intelligent exploration of ideas, however
inchoate. A certain degree of relaxation, familiarity, and
incompleteness of thought is to be expected in these letters. They will
be graded with less stringency, in other words. But remember that you
must still proofread and polish them so that the mechanics are correct.
Written Comments and Grades
As I read student work, what grade the work deserves becomes
clear to me rather quickly, just as anyone reading an article in a
magazine easily forms an estimate of how "good" the article is,
how
much information it conveys, how "smart" the writer has been on this
occasion. What comments I should write about a student's work is,
unfortunately, a question whose answer is never clear to me. Over many
years pondering this question, I have concluded that in many cases my
comments
are beside the point: it is too difficult to figure out what will
really help you to write better from one piece of your writing. The
best way for you to improve your writing is
to work hard at it and to write a lot, just as the best way to improve
your performance in a sport consists mostly of practice.
Procedure:
We will have two sorts of reading:
- Ancient: this is primary
source material
and as such is the most important material.
- Secondary reading: this is modern thought about the primary
source material.
- The Ancient reading is always the priority and should be prepared
first.
- The secondary reading must also be prepared.
- It is a good idea to reread the ancient reading after reading the
secondary reading.
Education is not preparation for life;
education is life itself.
(John Dewey, UVM 1879)