Diodorus Cronus and the "Master Argument"
Causal Determinism: multiple causes, overdetermination, remote
causes, background causes, etc. Not just a chain, but a complex
network.
Aristotle's "Chance"
Fate: a possible confusing equivocation to avoid
- "This is fated to happen." as shorthand for "This is part of a
fully determined causal network and is inevitable because of
that causal network." For example, "I became a gold medal
olympian because of training, the existence of the olympics, the
fact that Soundso Noonesdottir broke her leg, and because of
everything that led up to it."
- "Fate" as another word for "the causal network of the world"
- Saying that something is "fated" to happen in this sense
means that it is an event that is caused to happen as part of
the causal necessity of the world.
- vs.
- "This is fated to happen." as shorthand for "No matter what
else happens, this will happen." For example, "Even if I never
leave this couch, if I am fated to be a gold medal
olympian, it will happen. What can I do about it?"
- "Fate" as another word for things that happen (almost?) in
spite of the causal network.
- It's the idea that there are any number of actually possible
ways for X to happen, but the only certain thing is that X
will happen.
- Often it's cast into the past: there were any number of ways
for X to happen, and everything seemed against X happening,
but X was fated to happen in spite of it all.
THE SECOND ONE IS NOT STOIC FATE!
- Free will: the freedom of humans to make choices that are not
determined by prior causes or by divine intervention
- Claim: if you move without being caused to move, it is
either random (and you deserve no credit or blame) or it is
not.
- Question: If it is not random, how can it be uncaused?
- Related queston: Is there some third choice between caused
and random?
Compatibilism: the idea that free will and predetermination are
compatible: they can both be right.
Stoic compatibilism: the idea that responsibility for what a person
does and predetermination are compatible.